Welcome to Big City Pizza
At Big City Pizza, we share a passion for quality and community. Nestled in Elkhart, Indiana, our family-run restaurant serves extraordinary pizzas made from scratch, featuring hand-tossed crusts and house-made sauces. From the beloved Naples Margherita to the inventive Kansas City BBQ, our diverse menu caters to all tastes, including enticing cauliflower crust options. Guests rave about our generous portions and flavor-packed gyros, enriched by authentic homemade tzatziki. We pride ourselves on creating a warm, welcoming atmosphere where everyone feels at home. At Big City Pizza, every meal is a celebration of love, craft, and camaraderie. Join us for a memorable dining experience!
-
3251 Northview Dr, Elkhart, IN 46514, United States Hotline: +1 574-343-2191
Welcome to Big City Pizza, an inviting gem located at 3251 Northview Dr, Elkhart, IN, where passion for pizza meets a warm, family-friendly atmosphere. This charming establishment has quickly earned praise from locals and travelers alike, and it's easy to see why. With a menu that showcases an extraordinary variety of pizzas, starters, and a welcoming approach from the staff, each visit feels like a delightful culinary adventure.
- Build Your Own Pizza: The highlight here is the opportunity to create your very own pizza masterpiece. Choose from an array of ingredients or opt for classic offerings like the Mexico City Pizza, with zesty chorizo and jalapeños, or the NY City Meat Lovers, loaded with sausage, pepperoni, and bacon. The choice is yours!
- Overview of Unique Pizzas: Signature pizzas like the Chi-Town Deep Dish set the stage for a truly indulgent experience, taking 45 minutes to prepare and offering rich layers of flavor. Meanwhile, the Naples Margherita dazzles with fresh mozzarella and fragrant basil, making it a must-try for aficionados of Italian cuisine.
It's not just about pizza at Big City Pizza. The starters are worth a taste, too. Whether you indulge in the Cheesy Breadsticks or the flavorful Gyro Sauce Dip, each dish showcases the same attention to quality and flavor. Customers rave about their friendly service, which often puts a personal touch on the dining experience, making you feel right at home.
- Community Vibe: Visitors frequently mention how the family-run atmosphere of Big City Pizza adds to the experience. With a welcoming staff led by the lovable Miranda, patrons often leave not just satisfied, but with plans to return—just take it from Greg, Kelly, and Michael—they felt like they were dining with family.
- Quality and Affordability: Reviews highlight that Big City Pizza offers one of the best values in town. With quality ingredients and fair pricing, Michael Buck states, "The prices are absolutely fair, and the food just keeps getting better," which speaks volumes about their commitment to quality.
In conclusion, if you are seeking a place where every slice feels like a celebration, then Big City Pizza should be at the top of your list. Whether you are craving a traditional pizza or experimenting with cauliflower crust alternatives, this Elkhart eatery has got you covered. Be sure to stop by for a meal that is not just delicious, but also filled with heart. Your taste buds—and your stomach—will thank you!
Ordered a hand tossed pizza and a sandwich. Both were very delicious. The pizza was made with a lot of cheese and served steaming hot. They make their own crust and sauce. The philly sandwich used a soft roll and flavorful ingredients. We did not have dessert (no room), but the baklava looked very tasty. Will stop back again and want to try the Greek gyro. Thank you, Miranda!
Clean, friendly, and the food is excellent!!! We had two pizzas, one pepperoni and cheese and one meat lovers. The pizza crust is much like a Brooklyn style crust only slightly thicker. The toppings are first rate, not cheap and greasy. We also had a dozen wings with Buffalo style wing sauce and a Caesar salad. We are from western NY and we know wings. The sauce is authentic Franks and was spot on. The wings are baked not fried but they were well prepared, tasted great dipped in the sauce. The staff was all very attentive and truly welcoming. It was a great meal after a long day on the road. Thank you Big City Pizza!!!
The staff are nice, I think because it is a family-run restaurant. The prices are actually some of the cheapest in town, especially for the high quality of the food. They have a great lunch special Wednesday, Thursday, Friday if you've never had it. It's a great deal. Go check it out. I did not want to get the smallest pizza which is a personal 10-in so I got a 12-in medium and then I could only eat half of it. It is big. Also got a Caesar salad so I had way too much food. The salad is actually really big and very good as well.
The Chicago style pizza was absolutely delicious. Fresh handmade dough and the sauce was absolutely amazing also made in house, the cheese was delectable and so very tasty the jalapeño sauce was hands down the best sauce I had in a long time. Miranda was an absolute delight and fun to speak with. The atmosphere is a small laid back place and all together is very welcoming. Like coming home to a family I never knew I had. See you very soon.
If you want the best pizza in town, least I say Michiana, look no further. Big City Pizza got you covered. Although I missed taking a picture of the chicken bacon ranch large pizza I also ordered along with the amazing gyro, I have to tell you the pizza was fabulous! The crust was great and the toppings were amazing! I actually didn’t get to take a picture of the pizza because we ate it too quickly! As for the gyro, the homemade taziki which was light and flavorful was great! I rate my gyros based on the sauce because that’s what makes or breaks it. Too many restaurants are using sour cream in the sauce instead of Greek yogurt which is the correct method and that’s what this place does! The people there were wonderful. From the youth working behind the register to the owners running the house and kitchen, everyone was soo nice! The place was clean and everything was above and beyond! Thanks!
This is the third or fourth time that we've had Big City Pizza so I feel like this is a legitimate review. The staff has been friendly and exceptional from the beginning. The prices are absolutely Fair and the food just keeps getting better. It's nice to see somebody taking pride in their craft
The owner of Big City, Miranda, is such a wonderful woman. She is such a sweetheart and a master of the thin crust! They have a good variety of pizza options and she'll make it anyway you want it. And for fair prices!
My wife and I were having a party. We made a rather large order. The people are so friendly and the pizza and cheesy garlic sticks were a big hit. We'd definitely recommend it!